View Single Post
Old 08-13-2015, 11:11 PM   #13
Adonis
Tsk Tsk
 
Adonis's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: Beer Goggles
Posts: 4,834
Battle Record: 36-34


Champed
- Lime Green Poetry Association
- NFL Pick'em 2016-17

Rep Power: 9946449
Adonis has a brilliant futureAdonis has a brilliant futureAdonis has a brilliant futureAdonis has a brilliant futureAdonis has a brilliant futureAdonis has a brilliant futureAdonis has a brilliant futureAdonis has a brilliant futureAdonis has a brilliant futureAdonis has a brilliant futureAdonis has a brilliant future
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Pharaohs Army View Post
Ok I know this usually isn't a place for feedback on writings, but with the particular verse I am talking about, the voting is over and the thread is closed. And this is a discussion area so w/e, sue me.

Don't wanna simply PM it, because you never know when someone else's feedback on someone else's shit could help someone else, however slightly.
Particularly when it's feedback from someone awesome -- like me.
@Godcomplex
I've looked at your Week 6 championship with Rakontur.
First off, a bunch more qualifiers to my comments
1 - my comment here narrowly focuses on your 2nd verse
2 - i'm specifically talking about rhyme&structure
3 - frankly I am talking about it as it relates to "normal" "rap" verses, because it flowed like one. And because I want to.
4 - you may already know this,

but I feel it is important to be said

In that 2nd verse I see tools of yours which in my opinion you do not utilize enough. Rarely has it jumped out at me in the things you write, primarily because you are usually doing some more complex structures and vocabulary.

The journey of a young traveler,
Whose journey is purely magical,
Imagine having a soul, with happiness sown.
Yet, ghosts still attack as if spoken to bad
But, with one strike of his staff their emotions collapse.
Protected by a talisman created by some savages,
But, its powers are marvelous. With it-
An orphan can survive his fatherless apocalypse.

As, for sacred geometry reflecting consciousness,
That's just deceit used to mentally soften us.
I hope you've enjoyed discussing with us,
How you went from being child into taking them for hostages.


What I see here is a very fluid flow with a different kind of scheme than your usual.
One could argue that a writer, in a certain sense, might "dumb things down" for these affects. However that is not always a bad thing if "said dumbing down" involves a meticulous effort to make things flow, and more importantly be succinct while still being powerful.

I am biased of course because I do enjoy these kind of rhyme schemes with quick hitting multis, some of them being on the same line... Sometimes just doing a rhyme couplet and then changing the rhyme on the next couplet, but sometimes carrying it on for more than 2 lines.

Frankly if you had done the same style in the first verse I thought the entirety would have been more complete&connected, but perhaps you purposefully went for a contrast.

Which is fine. All I am saying is, take a look at that 2nd verse which you yourself wrote, and try to understand why I like it.. by examining it yourself moreso than my convoluted multitude of reasons I've laid out here.

Long story short, I think you should "try it more".. Certainly not with every piece you do, and certainly don't force it when you don't feel it's appropriate. But keep experimenting. It never hurts to add another knife to the drawer.. to throw that changeup when the reader is expecting a fastball.


This is some powerful feed right here. The quoted portion from the artist formely known as Buddha, yet will still be called so, maybe GOD, undecided, is really dope. The couplets you, Buddha, went with are hitting stride to perfection. I actually didn't even catch this when I read it, But I'm still proud of the outcome. I feel like you, Buddha, have a top 3 skill set in recent history of the aowl dating back to season one even, but utilizing all of your upper echelon bag of tricks don't always mesh. I know I'm more of a fan then most because I take my time and read your shit in awe over the pure knowledge you drop, and this to me makes you great, great in the literal sense. But it, at the same time, takes you down a notch. What pharaoh eluded to regarding dumbing down, I feel like you have yet to discover that happy median, and only the great ones and persistent ones do. I know you are persistent, and there is a green zone somewhere between dropping your knowledge on a scale where even I can understand, yet reaching the masses of say Tali Rodriguez or @sacrifice (come play). Basically, just keep being you because that shit is two thumbs up brother


Great feed Pharaoh, no clue who you are but you cross me as deep thinker I feel like you should sign in tonight
__________________
I'm tryna fuck like A-don-is

TUPAC SHAKUR
Adonis is offline   Reply With Quote