Okay so this one is a hard battle to judge for me. Jil, here is the best reason I can offer why I wasn't feeling the np. Design is what, a two-syllable word right? De-sign. What you did was you tried to fit another 2-syllable word into the second half of the word using "ign". Eye-ing. What you tried to do was Des-eyeing..but what it comes off as is Des-Eyen (pronounced "ine" as in "shine"). So Design is a 2-syllable word. Eyeing is a 2-syllable word, and you're using 3 letters to make that happen. "Ign" and "eyeing" doesn't work imo. This, even though everything else ab ur bar was great, collapses the entire concept bc it was built around the np.
Destroyer, in my eyes, should have won bc of this. BUT I'm a very principled guy, and I have to be consistent, or at least try my hardest to lol. Last week there was a repeat Vivian Banks concept, and due to the concept already being used in this league I had to vote against it no matter how much better it was than the previous versions or his opponents.I liked the way he flipped the concept and how smooth and effortless it connected. But I cannot vote for his bar considering the jack n jill np has already been used before in this league.
v-Jil
|